Return to site

The Long Lag of Luddite Elections

November 10, 2026

New Zealand has voted. Now we wait.

After the election on 7 November, the preliminary result leaves the country facing a finely balanced outcome. Around 399,000 special votes were excluded from the election-night count. In a contest this close, those voters could change the shape of the next Parliament. Electoral Commission preliminary results

The official results are due on 27 November: twenty days after election day. Special votes include votes from overseas and from people who enrolled close to election day, whose names were not on the printed electoral roll. The ten-day allowance specifically gives overseas votes time to be returned. Special votes must pass eligibility checks before being included in the official count. How the official count works

Every eligible vote deserves to count. My frustration is with how long the process takes, and whether we are ambitious enough about making it better.

There is real work behind the wait. Special votes must be returned to the appropriate electorate and checked for eligibility. Ordinary votes are recounted, rolls are scrutinised, and results are checked. These safeguards matter. A close election makes accuracy more important, not less. How the official count works

But respecting those safeguards should not prevent us from asking whether the system could work differently.

I was able to ring up and cast my vote without going to a polling booth. That experience left me wondering why more people cannot have a similarly accessible option.

The distinction matters: voting by telephone dictation is not the same as voting through a website. New Zealand’s telephone service is available to eligible voters who are blind, partially blind, or have another physical disability that prevents them from marking their ballot without assistance. An electoral official records their choices. Telephone dictation voting

Yet the principle is powerful. We already recognise that participation should not depend on someone physically entering a voting place and marking a paper unaided.

Why stop there?

Online voting deserves serious consideration as an additional option. People manage important parts of their lives digitally. It is reasonable to ask what it would take to offer voting with comparable confidence.

It would be too easy, however, to declare it equally safe simply because other sensitive transactions happen online. A ballot must remain secret while its inclusion and the result remain trustworthy. Researchers examining Australia’s iVote system found serious weaknesses affecting privacy, integrity and verification. Those are problems a credible proposal must address. Independent iVote security research

I want that challenge taken seriously, alongside the challenge of exclusion.

A well-designed remote option could help people juggling work, caring responsibilities, transport difficulties or fatigue. It might also reach some people who are reluctant to visit a polling place. Easier access will not automatically create trust or increase turnout, but unnecessary effort should not be the reason someone stays out.

There is already a useful distinction in our system: overseas voters can download, complete and upload their voting papers, while general online voting is unavailable within New Zealand. That is not a complete digital voting system, but it shows that remote participation already has a place. Government voting guidance

The next step should be a serious programme of accessible design, independent testing and public scrutiny. Disabled people should help shape it from the beginning. Paper voting and in-person support should remain available.

Nor would online voting automatically eliminate every delay in producing a final result. Eligibility checks and scrutiny would still matter.

Calling an election system “Luddite” is provocative. The point is to challenge an assumption: that the way we have always voted must remain the way we vote.

I want every vote counted accurately. I also want us to ask how voting could become easier, more inclusive and, where possible, faster.

Democracy deserves both care and imagination.